When people purchase life insurance policies, they designate a beneficiary who will benefit from the policy’s proceeds. When the insured person dies, the policy’s beneficiary then receives a payout known as the death benefit.

Yahoo Finance’s recent article entitled “Will My Beneficiaries Pay Taxes on Life Insurance?” says the big advantage of buying a life insurance policy is that, upon death, your beneficiaries can get a substantial lump sum payment without taxation, unless the amount of the life insurance pushes your estate above the applicable federal estate tax exemption. In that case, your estate will need to pay the tax.

While death benefits are usually tax-free, there are a few situations where the beneficiary of a life insurance policy may have to pay taxes on the lump sum payout. When you earn income from interest, it’s typically taxable. Therefore, if the beneficiary decides to delay the payout instead of receiving it right away, the death benefit may continue to accumulate interest. The death benefit won’t be taxed. However, the beneficiary will typically pay taxes on the additional interest.

So, for example, if the decedent had an insurance policy with a $200,000 death benefit which pays to their daughter at death. The daughter submits a claim after the parent dies and receives $200,736. The $736 is interest generated on the amount of money held by the company post­ death until pay out. The death benefit of $200,000 is not taxable, but the $736 is income taxable as interest, just as though the beneficiary has held the $200,000 in a bank somewhere and generated $736 in interest.

Additionally, the value of the insurance policy is subject to estate tax in most cases. This is true for typical insurance policies where an individual owns a policy on their own life and the proceeds pay out at death (e.g. the $200,000 policy described above). The value of the insurance increases the size of your estate so that if your estate excludes your applicable gift and estate tax exclusion amount (currently about $13,000,000) then your estate will have estate tax to pay.

This obviously doesn’t affect too many people, but many term policies can dramatically increase estate sizes due to their high death benefits.  Some states also have their own inheritance or estate taxes to consider.

Estate planning attorneys, especially when the estate tax exemptions were lower, frequently used life insurance trusts, often called “ILITs” or “Irrevocable Life Insurance Trusts,” to combat this. As the estate tax exemption is currently expected to be cut in half in 2026, these kinds of trusts make sense to use now so that the value of the insurance is removed from your estate in anticipation of a lower exemption.  They work because the client doesn’t have ownership of the insurance policy. It is owned and maintained by the trust without any “incidences of ownership” so that the policy is not considered controlled by the decedent. They will often pay money to the trust which will in turn pay the insurance premiums during life.

I often recommend this to younger clients who are considering life insurance. They may never expect to be estate taxable, but as we don’t know what the future holds, or where politics will take us, we can remove the insurance from their estates now and so not worry about it.

If you want to know more about how life insurance impacts your estate plan, see this article:  https://galligan-law.com/role-of-insurance-in-estate-planning/

As a warning, I’m referring to taxation of life insurance at death. Transferring the policy, withdrawing money or taking a loan from the cash value and surrendering the policy can all have taxable components, so you would want to consult a CPA or attorney on the tax implications before proceeding.

To summarize, beneficiaries usually won’t have to pay taxes on life insurance proceeds. However, some situations can result in a taxable event and in some cases can be planned for in advance.

Reference: Yahoo Finance (Jan. 17, 2023) “Will My Beneficiaries Pay Taxes on Life Insurance?”