Will Contests – Does a “No-Contest” Clause Really Work?

A no-contest clause in your will may discourage a will contest.
A no-contest clause in your will may discourage a will contest.

We live in a litigious society. Unfortunately, even family members sometimes file lawsuits because they are dissatisfied with what their parents or loved ones leave them in a will or trust. Some are so disgruntled that they decide to contest or challenge the validity of a will or trust, which can delay its administration for years and result in thousands of dollars in legal fees. If you are concerned that any of your beneficiaries may seek to challenge your will or trust, a no-contest clause might be one method you can use to discourage them from pursuing this course of action.

What Is a No-Contest Clause?

A typical no-contest clause provides that a beneficiary who disputes the validity of a will forfeits any inheritance or benefit they otherwise would have received according to its terms. It will not prevent someone who is not a beneficiary named in your will or trust from contesting it though.

Are They Enforceable?

In Texas, no-contest clauses are enforceable unless the will contestant shows that he or she had “just cause” for contesting the will and that the will contest is in good faith. The goal is to discourage will contests that are not brought in good faith (for example, a person might threaten a will contest in the hopes that the rightful beneficiaries would be willing to settle for an amount less than the cost of defending the will contest),  but to allow contests for legitimate reasons, such as a forgery, or when a purported will is executed by an incapacitated person or a person who has been unduly influenced by another.

What Are the Pros and Cons?

These types of clauses have some advantages as well as some disadvantages, as listed below:

Pros of a no-contest clause

  • Honors your right to give your property to the parties you have chosen in the way you want, as expressed in your will or trust
  • Discourages baseless challenges to a will or trust by a disgruntled beneficiary
  • Discourages meritless lawsuits aimed at forcing a settlement by a dissatisfied beneficiary
  • Avoids lengthy and expensive litigation that will deplete your estate and delay administration

Cons of no-contest clause

  • Causes a beneficiary to suffer a forfeiture of his or her inheritance for enforcing his or her right to challenge the will’s validity
  • Impedes the court’s ability to determine if the will or trust is valid and ensure that it was not executed as a result of unlawful means, for example, where an unscrupulous child convinces an elderly parent with dementia to sign a new will beneficial to that child shortly before the parent’s death

Create an Estate Plan That Keeps the Peace

If you see trouble brewing and are concerned that family members could contest your will or trust, a no-contest clause is one tool that could discourage dissatisfied beneficiaries from seeking to have it declared invalid. Another possibility that could forestall a will or trust contest is to conduct a family meeting during which you can explain your reasons for distributing your money and property in the way you have. An experienced estate planning attorney can help you create an estate plan for your unique circumstances and to employ all available tools, including a no-contest clause, to decrease possible conflict within the family

You may also be interested in https://galligan-law.com/does-your-executor-know-what-to-do/.

Continue ReadingWill Contests – Does a “No-Contest” Clause Really Work?

Twelve Reasons to Update your Estate Plan

Clients know they are supposed to review their estate plans, but don’t know when to do it. Here are twelve times when it makes sense to review your plan.

Estate planning lawyers hear it all the time—people meaning to update their estate plan, but somehow never getting around to actually getting it done. The only group larger than the ones who mean to “someday,” are the ones who don’t think they ever need to update their documents, says the article “12 Different Times When You Should Update Your Will” from Kiplinger. The problems become abundantly clear when people die, and survivors learn that their will or trust is so out-of-date that it creates a world of problems for a grieving family.  For the purposes of this article I’ll focus on property planning, meaning wills and trusts, but there are lots of other reasons to review and update your entire estate plan.

There are some wills and trusts that do stand the test of time, but they are far and few between. An obvious example is that some people shift from wills to trusts as their primary estate planning vehicle.  Families also undergo all kinds of changes, and those changes should be reflected in the will or trust. Here are twelve times in life when wills and trusts need to be reviewed:

Welcoming a child to the family. The focus is on naming a guardian and a trustee to oversee their finances. The will and trust should be flexible to accommodate additional children in the future.  In some cases, a new child may disrupt the estate plan if no provisions are made for them.

Divorce is a possibility. Don’t wait until the divorce is underway to make changes. Do it beforehand. If you die before the divorce is finalized, your spouse will have marital rights to your property. Once you file for divorce, in many states you are not permitted to change your estate plan, until the divorce is finalized. Make no moves here, however, without the advice of your attorney.

Your divorce has been finalized. If you didn’t do it before, update your estate plan now. Don’t neglect updating beneficiaries on life insurance and any other accounts that may have named your ex as a beneficiary.

When your child(ren) marry. You may be able to mitigate the lack of a prenuptial agreement, by creating trusts for your beneficiary, so anything you leave your child will be protected in the case of their divorce.

Your beneficiary has problems with drugs or money. Money left directly to a beneficiary is at risk of being attached by creditors or dissolving into a drug habit. Updating your estate plan to includes trusts that allow a trustee to only distribute funds under optimal circumstances protects your beneficiary and their inheritance for both themselves and for later beneficiaries.

Named executor, trustee or beneficiary dies. Your old will or trust may have a contingency plan for what should happen if a beneficiary, executor or trustee dies, but you should probably revisit the plan. Many times, clients have one answer for what happens if a fiduciary or beneficiary die while it is hypothetical, but feel differently once it happens.  If a named executor or trustee dies and you don’t update the estate plan, then what happens if the second dies?

A young family member grows up. Most people name a parent as their executor or trustee, then a spouse or trusted sibling. Two or three decades go by. An adult child may now be ready to take on the task of handling your estate.  This is one of the most obvious and common reasons for a younger client to update their estate plan.

New laws go into effect. In recent months, there have been many big changes to the law that impact estate planning, from the SECURE Act to the CARES act. Ask your estate planning attorney every few years, if there have been new laws that are relevant to your estate plan.  It is also a great idea to subscribe to legal blogs (like this one) to stay up to date on changes.

An inheritance, windfall or downfall. If you come into a significant amount of money, your tax liability changes. You’ll want to update your will, so you can do efficient tax planning as part of your estate plan.

Can’t find your will and/or trust? If you can’t find the original documents, especially with the will, then you need new documents. Copies of wills may only be probated with extra steps, so it is far better to redo the documents which will also serve to update it legally.

Buying property in another country or moving to another country. Some countries have reciprocity with America. However, transferring property to an heir in one country may be delayed, if the will needs to be probated in another country. Ask your estate planning attorney, if you need wills for each country in which you own property.  It is also worth considering changes if you acquire real property in a new state which may require probating in two states.

Family and friends are enemies. Friends have no rights when it comes to your estate plan. If you suspect that your family may push back to any bequests to friends, consider adding a “No Contest” clause to disinherit family members who try to elbow your friends out of the estate.

In all cases, it is important to review your estate plan every few years, but looking for these reasons to update our estate plan will help.  Changing your estate plan is also not as involved as one might think.  Changes to wills often require a new will, changes to trusts take a variety of forms (see here https://galligan-law.com/amending-a-trust-what-are-your-options/) but are often not very involved.

If you haven’t reviewed your estate plan recently or need assistance with a review or updates, please call our office today.

Reference: Kiplinger (May 26, 2020) “12 Different Times When You Should Update Your Will”

Continue ReadingTwelve Reasons to Update your Estate Plan

How a Letter to Your Executor or Trustee Conveys Your Wishes

A letter to your executor or trustee can help clarify your wishes and promote your goals for your beneficiaries.
A letter to your executor or trustee can help clarify your wishes and promote your goals for your beneficiaries.

A detailed, informative letter can be invaluable to those you have designated to carry out your wishes after you’re gone, says the article “Why You Should Write a Letter to Your Executor—and What to Say in It” from The Wall Street Journal. Your last will and testament or living trust does have many directions. However, there may be things you want your executor or trustee to know that may not be included in your will or living trust. This is especially important if death is sudden. The letter, which you should sign and date, can help prevent potential disputes by minimizing any confusion around your intentions, priorities and goals.

One thing to keep in mind when writing out instructions is that, if you have a will-based estate plan, the executor is charged with the responsibility of paying your debts and final expenses and then distributing the remaining assets to the beneficiaries. So the executorship is really a relatively short-term position. If you have a trust-based estate plan, it is your successor trustee who has these duties.

Because the executor has no control over your assets after they are distributed to your beneficiaries, a letter of instruction will be most helpful if you have created trusts for your beneficiares in your will or living trust. Think of the trustee of these trusts as being involved long-term. That said, there may be situations when a letter to the executor would be very helpful. For example, a letter could explain why you have decided to treat beneficiaries differently in your estate plan.

Here are some things to consider when drafting a letter to your executor or trustee.

Your thoughts about wealth. Share your story about how you came to the assets that you are leaving in your will. How was your wealth created, what do you value and what are your long-term goals for your wealth? Do you want family members to invest the assets, so they grow over generations, or do you want them used for college education costs for grandchildren?

Describe key players in the family. It is best if your executor or trustee knows the members of your family.  However, they may not know the family dynamics or history. Giving them your insights, may help them anticipate issues. Does one child tend to take over and speak for everyone, without being asked? Are there substance abuse issues in the family that need to be considered? Share your concerns, so your executor or trustee can be mindful of how the family works (or doesn’t) as a unit.

What matters to you? This is especially important, if you don’t want your beneficiaries to be dependent upon their inheritance, instead of becoming self-reliant. Share your values to encourage their earned success. Make it clear if you want to protect the family wealth, so it can be used to empower future generations and for family members to be responsible for their own financial well-being. Evidence of your intent will help a trustee if a beneficiary challenges the way a trustee is managing and making distributions from the trust.

Give your  trustee the power to make decisions, even when that means saying no. Considering the size of your wealth and the family members who are your beneficiaries, you probably have a good idea of who would do what with their inheritance. If you don’t want your wealth to be used for a start-up by a son whose financial management capabilities are questionable, say so in the letter to your trustee. If you are hopeful that a daughter will use her inheritance for a down payment on a home for her family, you should also express that.

A good estate plan is not just about who gets what and when. A good estate plan is one which tries to minimize conflict and promotes the values you hold dear. That’s why it’s important to consult with an experienced estate planning attorney who has worked with many families and who understands the challenges and pitfalls that are presented any time wealth is transferred from one generation to the next.

You may also be interest in https://galligan-law.com/does-your-executor-know-what-to-do/.

Reference: The Wall Street Journal (April 8, 2020) “Why You Should Write a Letter to Your Executor—and What to Say in It”

 

Continue ReadingHow a Letter to Your Executor or Trustee Conveys Your Wishes