Making a Gift on your Deathbed?

A new case out of Tax Court centers on the question of when a “deathbed gift” is complete for federal estate and gift tax purposes.  Clients make gifts to reduce the federal estate tax, or reduce it to a manageable size, especially as we draw closer to 2026 when the estate tax exemption will be a far lower number.

The two tax law provisions affecting this are described in the article “Tax Court Says When Deathbed Gifts Are Complete” from accounting WEB:

Annual gift tax exclusion. A taxpayer may give gifts to recipients under the annual gift tax exclusion without incurring any federal gift taxes. The exclusion, indexed for inflation in $1,000 increments, is $16,000 per recipient in 2022. It’s doubled to $32,000 for joint gifts made by a married couple. Estates can be reduced with planned use of the annual gift tax exclusion. For instance, if a taxpayer and a spouse give the maximum $16,000 to five relatives for five years in a row, they will have transferred $800,000 ($32,000 x 5 x 5) out of their estate, free of taxes.  This is enhanced when you make gifts of different assets that can be discounted in value.

Now, every time I write an article about gifting, I always temper it.  You’ll noticed from the next paragraph that the estate tax doesn’t apply to too many people, and so may not be advantageous.  It is also true that assets not in your estate at your death do not receive a step up in basis.  This applies to things like stock, real estate and many other non-cash items, which means gifting may ultimately increase the total tax to beneficiaries instead of reducing it.  So, it is worth discussing this with a professional before starting a gifting campaign.  See our website for a much broader approach to estate tax planning.  https://galligan-law.com/practice-areas/estate-tax-planning/  

Unified estate and gift tax exemption. In addition to the annual gift exemption, gifts may be sheltered from tax by the unified estate and gift tax exemption. As of this writing, the exemption is $10 million, indexed for inflation, which brings it to $12.06 million in 2022. It is scheduled to drop to $5 million, plus inflation indexing, in 2026.

Using the exemption during the taxpayer’s lifetime reduces the available estate shelter upon death. These two provisions give even very wealthy taxpayers a great deal of flexibility regarding liquid assets.

In the new case, Estate of DeMuth v. Comm’r, TC Memo 2022-72, 7/12/22, the agent under a power of attorney for a Pennsylvania resident made gifts of the annual gift tax exclusion on an annual basis from 2007 to 2014 to his siblings and other family members, in accordance with the POA.

The father’s health began to fail in 2015 and he passed away on September 11. On September 6, five days before he died, the son wrote eleven checks, totaling $464,000 from the father’s investment account.

Some recipients deposited the checks before the decedent’s death, but others did not. Only one check was paid by the investment account before the decedent’s death.

The question before the Tax Court: are the gifts complete and removed from the decedent’s estate?

According to the IRS, any checks deposited before death should be excluded from the taxable estate, but the Tax Court looked to the state’s law to determine the outcome of the other checks. The Tax Court ruled the checks not deposited in time must be included in the decedent’s taxable estate.

As a fun aside for our Pennsylvania friends, Pennsylvania also has inheritance tax, which attaches to transfers made within a year of death with a $3,000 exemption per recipient.  So, the estate would still have to pay inheritance tax on the completed transfers, although the inheritance tax rates are nothing compared to the federal estate tax rates.

The estate planning lesson to be learned? Timing matters. If checks are written as part of the plan to minimize taxes, they must be deposited promptly to ensure they will be considered as gifts and reduce the taxable estate.  In all cases, it is better to have, and execute, a plan of action before trying to resolve taxes on your deathbed.

Reference: accounting WEB (Aug. 26,2022) “Tax Court Says When Deathbed Gifts Are Complete”

Continue ReadingMaking a Gift on your Deathbed?

Will Making a Gift Conflict with Medicaid?

People usually make gifts for three reasons—because they want to provide for the recipient, because they want to protect assets, or minimize tax liability. However, gifting in one’s elder years can have expensive and unintended consequences, as reported in the article “IRS standards for gifting differ from Medicaid” from The News-Enterprise, especially with Medicaid.

As a quick aside, if you’ve read any of my articles on gifting, you know I preach caution.  Way too many people make gifts because of a perceived benefit, and don’t consult a professional to determine whether there is a benefit.  That said, for the purposes of this article, I’m going to focus on Medicaid gift tax consequences as opposed to all of the other pros and cons in making gifts.

A primary reason for most people to make gifts is tax planning.  The IRS gift tax becomes expensive, if gifts are large. However, each individual has a lifetime gift exemption and, as of this writing, it is $12.06 million, which is historically high. A married couple may make a gift of $24.12 million. Most people don’t get anywhere near these levels. Those who do are advised to do estate and tax planning to protect their assets.

The IRS also allows an annual exemption. For 2022, the annual exemption is $16,000 per person. Anyone can gift up to $16,000 per person and to multiple people, without reducing their lifetime exemption.

However, the more real danger is the effect of a gift on Medicaid or long-term care benefits.  People, and frequently financial advisors and non-attorney professionals, often confuse the IRS annual exclusion with Medicaid requirements for eligibility. IRS gift tax rules are totally different from Medicaid rules.

Medicaid does not offer an annual gift exclusion. Medicaid penalizes any gift made within 60 months before applying to Medicaid, unless there has been a specific exception.  The Veterans Administration may also penalize gifts made within 36 months before applying for certain VA programs based on eligibility.

For Medicaid purposes, gifts include outright gifts to individuals, selling property for less than fair market value, transferring assets to an irrevocable trust, or giving away partial interests.  Some gifts are expressly permitted, such as gifts between spouses.  Also, most states have some species of an exception for very small gifts, but that definition varies widely.

For example, in Texas there is no exception for small gifts.  However, Medicaid staff is instructed not to inquire into potential gift transactions for less than $200 total in a month.  That doesn’t create a strategy of gifting typically, but it avoids Medicaid penalties when Grandma gives $50 to a grandchild for their birthday.

The penalty for gifting in Medicaid is a penalty period.  In short, Medicaid looks at your eligibility, and once otherwise eligible will calculate a penalty period by dividing the value of your gifts by a penalty rate based upon the daily average cost of a nursing home in the year of the gift.  So, if you gave away $50,000 and the penalty rate is $250 per day, you are ineligible for 200 days.  During this time you’ll have to find a way to pay yourself before Medicaid will.

So, gifting where Medicaid may be an issue in the future often has very real and dangerous consequences.  That doesn’t mean gifting can’t be useful in Medicaid, as sometimes gifting is an express strategy for eligibility, but anyone making gifts should do so at the advice of an attorney.

Reference: The News-Enterprise (Aug. 6, 2022) “IRS standards for gifting differ from Medicaid”

Continue ReadingWill Making a Gift Conflict with Medicaid?